Aryaman S

Outrage as EA Turn To AI Slop For FC 26 Silver Icon Cards

FC 26

For years, EA Sports’ promotional cards were beautiful artworks that captured the imagination of millions of gamers worldwide. Each Ultimate Team card was a carefully crafted work of digital art, where talented designers poured their creativity into vibrant backgrounds, dynamic player poses, and intricate visual effects that made legendary footballers leap off the screen. Each theme had a different feeling be it Thunderstruck, Winter Wildcard, Radioactive etc. You could see and feel the effect and effort that went into these promos.

The design teams at EA Sports understood that each card needed to feel special, to capture not just a player’s abilities but their essence and their story. So what changed?

Electronic Arts has been increasingly investing in AI and machine learning research to power their games, and this technological shift has now reached their promotional card design process. EA Sports is leveraging AI technologies to enhance various aspects of their gaming experience, and card generation appears to be the latest frontier.

While AI tools can rapidly produce variations of card layouts, backgrounds, and effects, they lack the nuanced understanding that human designers brought to each project. Not to mention the mistakes it makes. The AI usage is very evident in these leaks for the FC 26 Silver Icon cards as part of the World Tour: Silver Superstars

It does not even require an eagle eye. The difference is very clear, Sir Bobby Charlton T-Shirt cuffs are off a different colour. One is the colour of the T-Shirt and one is light pink. How EA can allow such an obvious error to make it through is questionable.

Another error, AI has a habit of making mistakes when generating fingers. Here as you can see, Zlatan has 6 fingers. Just like the arm cuff error before, this is also an error that is very easy to spot.

Beyond the aesthetic implications, EA Sports’ shift to AI generated promotional cards represents a concerning trend in the creative industries. The talented designers who once crafted these digital masterpieces now find their specialized skills less valued in an industry increasingly focused on automation and cost reduction. These aren’t just job losses they represent the erosion of a creative profession that required years to master.

The ripple effects extend beyond EA Sports itself. Freelance designers who once contributed to promotional card projects, specialized design agencies that partnered with gaming companies, and the broader ecosystem of creative professionals who supported these projects all face uncertainty as AI systems replace human creativity.

Look at the difference between the two, Gullit’s curly hair looking like Medusa. The way the green blends onto the card and forms a demonic monster at the back. Each element on the picture forms a story and a link to the player. This is something AI cannot achieve and hopefully EA takes note of this.

The irony is palpable in a game that celebrates the beautiful game and the emotional connections fans have with their sporting heroes, the visual representation of these players is now being relegated to algorithmic generation.

As EA Sports continues down this path, the gaming community will ultimately decide whether the efficiency gains of AI generated content are worth the loss of human creativity and cultural understanding. The promotional cards may still function as gameplay elements, but whether they will continue to serve as cherished collectibles that capture the magic of football remains to be seen. Given how much cheaper and quicker it is to generate these, EA will most likely continue making these cards via AI. We are slowly seeing the shift to AI being crammed into our lives.

Leave a comment